Patient Reviews & Testimonials

• Kelsey Doyle 5 Stars!    We took our newborn for ear molding today and had a wonderful experience. We drove 3 hours to this practice and are so glad we did. Everyone was so friendly, we were given a quick and timely appointment, and the appointment was quick and easy but thorough. Highly recommend!

• Jessica Hanf 5 Stars!   Dr. Carniol and his team are excellent! My 2 month old required ear molding to help with some of the cartilage in his ear and we saw results in just one week. I’m beyond happy with the results we were able to achieve after a few weeks and I’m so grateful for him and his team. They are so kind, caring and helpful especially when dealing with an infant. I definitely will be recommending Dr. Carniol to friends and family!

• Chelsea Mouta 5 Stars!   Dr. Carniol treated our newborn’s ear crimp and we could not have been happier with the experience. The doctor and his staff were incredible with our newborn, so knowledgeable about the process and clear about treatment options. They scheduled several appointments with us throughout the process to monitor progress and we were very happy with the results. We would absolutely recommend him for this treatment again!

• Christina Fiorentino 5 Stars!  Dr. Carniol removed a skin tag from our 1-month-old baby’s face. The staff was incredible and made us feel very comfortable. They were so caring with her during the entire procedure. Her face looks great and the scar healed very quickly. I would highly recommend this practice!

Amy Malkin 5 Stars!   Dr. Eric Carniol and his staff are absolutely amazing, and I cannot recommend them enough. From the initial consultation to the follow-up appointment, everything was clearly explained, and Dr. Carniol truly takes his time to make you feel comfortable and at ease. The results of my son’s incisionless otoplasty exceeded our expectations, and we are so grateful for his newfound confidence. Thank you so much!

RR  5 Stars!   I’m truly grateful to have had Dr. Carniol for my procedure. Everyone in the office was exceptionally attentive and organized, making the entire experience seamless. Dr. Carniol is an incredibly gifted surgeon with a remarkable attention to detail. Thanks to him, I feel a renewed sense of confidence and self-esteem, and I wholeheartedly encourage anyone to seek out Carniol Plastic Surgery.

• Janice 5 Stars!  (Upper blepharoplasty experience) I was awake for the procedure in his office. He and Shannon were wonderful at keeping me calm and informed regarding what I needed to do to ensure my recovery. I returned several times over the course of the next few weeks and they really stayed on top of my case.  Everyone in the office was terrific and there is just such an upbeat atmosphere there. It’s clear that the staff and Dr. Carniol and his father, who is his partner in the practice, get along wonderfully. I always felt that I had a coordinated team behind me…[My ophthalmologist] upon examining my eye, she said that Dr. Carniol had done a wonderful job, that I had perfect closure of the eyelids…and that she was very impressed with his work.  Dr. Carniol is a true artist. He didn’t just aim to make me look younger. He wanted me to look refreshed, but even more importantly, he wanted me to be able to see better. Dr. Carniol spent time talking to me and taking note of my facial expressions so that he would be able to take them into consideration when adjusting my eyelids. He explained that if he was too aggressive in removing extra skin, I might no longer be able to make the same facial expressions that are such a part of me.  Dr. Carniol looked at me as a complete person and the results are three-fold. My vision is greatly improved, and I look younger and refreshed while still retaining my facial “personality.”  I cannot recommend Dr. Eric Carniol and his staff highly enough!

• DN5 Stars!  Dr. Carniol is a technically brilliant surgeon. In addition, he has a great bedside manner and his whole staff makes you feel comfortable. Dr. Carniol blends his medical expertise with an artist’s eye. You’re in excellent hands.

• AA 5 Stars!  Two surgeries and a bunch of follow ups later, I would highly recommend Dr. Carniol to anyone.

• KS     5 Stars!    Dr. Carniol and his staff were outstanding!  He was kind, patient and understanding.  He took time to explain the procedure to me and make sure I understood and had no questions.  He made me comfortable and made me feel safe. His staff was always kind with a smile and welcoming.  I cannot recommend this office highly enough!

• L Q 5 Stars!  Was refer by one of his previous client who had septoplasty with a great outcome. Like his previous client i had trouble breathing from my deviated septum and was relying on nasal decongestion spray to breath. Finally decided to meet Dr. Eric Carniol about my deviated septum. I decided to go with septoplasty and he explain the procedure in great detail. Was given post op instructions well ahead of time with clear instructions that i needed to practice nasal rinse prior to surgery. I met with Dr. Carniol one week prior to surgery and review procedure again and he answer any questions i had. He also made sure that i knew how to rinse before surgery. Had surgery with no complications rinsing helped a lot. The only issue was waiting to have nose compacting tube removed. Once out no trouble breathing since. I would recommend him 100%.

• María Villalobos 5 Stars!   We enjoy our visits with Dr. Eric Carniol. He is respectful and listens well to my son’s concerns. He is very insightful and knowledgeable. His care plan helped. My son’s Nasal turbinate reduction and septoplasty went very well. He is recovering and we are so thankful we found Dr. Carniol.

• Toby Franklin 5 Stars!     Dr. Eric Carniol did a fantastic job performing my VivAer surgery for nasal remodeling. My ability to breathe easily through my nose has dramatically improved since the surgery this fall. Additionally, Dr. Carniol and his office team were thoughtful and patient in their approach to surgery prep, the procedure itself, and aftercare. When you meet with many doctors, you are keenly aware that the provider is trying to wrap up the discussion as quickly as possible and move on to the next patient. I never felt this way with Dr. Carniol or anyone in his office. I would absolutely use Dr. Carniol again for any future plastic surgery.

• Wajahat Azim 5 Stars!    Dr. Eric Carniol is a top notch ENT specialist and Surgeon. His diagnosis and support is always thorough. Office staff as well is very competent, friendly and professional. My family was under the care of Dr. Eric and we are grateful for the way he supported. Strongly recommended.

• K 5 Stars! Dr. Eric Carniol is an amazing surgeon — extremely skilled, caring, and truly compassionate. His staff is next level: friendly, knowledgeable, and always welcoming. From start to finish, the experience was exceptional. Would absolutely recommend!

• Jared Gutman 5 Stars!  Outstanding doctor! Extremely knowledgeable, really helped me with my condition.  Would highly recommend!

• Alec W 5 Stars!    I was hit by a car while crossing the street some months ago, my nose was crushed and completely crooked. Dr. Eric Carniol was able to squeeze me in the day after the accident which prevented further swelling. Within a matter of minutes of sitting down for my appointment, my nose was straight again. He meticulously moved each bone back into place, both on the inside and outside of my nose and I felt immediate relief. It is evident that Dr. Carniol is not just an expert in everything nose and face, but passionate about helping his patients. He is the type of doctor you hope you get to see whenever you’re at the hospital. He will explain what he’s doing, ask if you have any questions, have a conversation with you, and laugh with you as he cracks a joke. Two weeks ago, Dr. Eric Carniol performed a septoplasty on me to improve my breathing after the accident worsened my deviated septum. I was breathing better within a week, and now I’m breathing better than ever. The operation was complication-free and recovery was quick. After the surgery, he made sure I was recovering well with 1-week and 2-week checkup appointments. As someone who lives with chronic migraine, I’ve been especially impacted by the reduction in migraine-attack frequency since the surgery. Dr. Carniol is a highly skilled surgeon who genuinely cares about his patients. My nose is straight, my breathing is better than ever, and my quality of life has been vastly improved thanks to him.

• Brenda 5 Stars!   The office is calm, clean, and relaxing. The women who greet you upon arriving are polite and knowledgeable.  Dr. Eric Carniol is different from any other doctor I have visited.  He answers every question you might have, has a very pleasant manor about him, and doesn’t push any procedures that you are not ready for or interested in. I am honestly saying that this doctor is practically PAIN FREE! He doesn’t care to see his patients uncomfortable in any way, and checks on how you are feeling, repeatedly.  Truly,  he is a found miracle among the huge number of doctors that claim they can help you. If there is anything I can say to encourage you to visit with Dr Eric Carniol, it’s that you will NOT be disappointed!!

• Frank Petrilli   5 Stars!  I adopted the motto. I walked in 71 and I walked out 51 the results were exactly what I was looking for so to say that I’m totally elated would be an understatement I know consider Dr Eric. My BFF. To use the line from the movie Analyze This. Doc your good your really good!!
• Veronica Yankowski 5 Stars!   Dr.Carniol and his staff are just the best. He is knowledgeable on all of the latest procedures in the industry and is so thorough. Whether you’re going for your first Botox or have had things done before, you’ll always feel comfortable and most importantly get the results you’re looking for.
• Ariusz K 5 Stars! Dr. Carniol is very knowledgeable, provides detailed explanations and performs outstanding treatments. He is also very compassionate and treats you like family.
• SJ 5 Stars!
• MF 5 Stars! Office staff is efficient and sweet. Dr Carniol is the best. He explains all possibilities for treatment. No pressure. Makes his suggestions. Always available for questions

Catherine P 5 Stars! Dr Eric Carniol is very knowledgeable, professional, and friendly. He really makes his patients feel at ease and explains every step of the procedure clearly and thoroughly.

• Lad cat 5 Stars!    I emphasize there is NO WAY anyone else could have ever connected with my daughter and eased her out of her most terrified and anxious state of consciousness the way Dr Carniol did. NO way. NOBODY else.  He is absolutely magic. There is no denying he is incredible. In fact, my daughter decided she was going to call him her “surgician.”  I don’t think I even need to continue. Doesn’t that name say it all?!
• Kathryn Larkin 5 Stars!    Dr. Eric Carniol has been amazing! I was referred to him after a cycling accident. I had bruised rips, deep wounds on my nose, arms and stomach and required 8 stitches in my chin. I looked like Frankenstein when I first visited his office and now, with his help, I am back to looking and feeling like myself again!    He took the time to listen to my concerns, inspect the wounds and discuss a holistic plan. I am so grateful for his help and would recommend him and his practice to anyone looking for a plastic surgeon!
• Sabah Talip 5 Stars!    Dr. Carniol is the BEST!!  He took such good care of my son…..twice!  It’s obvious he’s a father himself.  He is so wonderful with children.  He went above and beyond to give the best care, and we are so thankful.
• Nicole Worden 5 Stars!   I can’t say enough positive things about Dr. Carniol and his staff (Jess and Iris). Dr. Carniol met us first thing the next morning after our pediatrician let us know my 3.5 year old’s eyelid did not stay “glued” shut from the urgent care the day before from a freaky fall into the side of his sister’s crib. He removed the glue, cleaned up my son’s cut and stitched him up. He explained everything to my son so he knew what to expect and was so patient with his questions, crying, etc. We were at ease with his procedure and recovery. He will have minimal scarring thanks to Dr. Carniol and for that I am so so grateful! I hope to never see him again, but if we ever need stitches for our kids I know exactly who to call.

• Mary Ellen Maddalone 5 Stars!   We’ve used Dr. Carniol multiple times for stitches on my son’s face. He is amazing! Aside from doing a wonderful job he makes a horrible and stressful experience for you and your child so much better. He is incredibly kind and warm, as is everyone in his office. Cannot recommend him enough!

• Carmela a 5 Stars!      My toddler needed emergency stitches at 8 pm one evening after hitting our coffee table on his eyebrow. I had brought him to pm pediatrics who advised I would need a plastic surgeon since it was an injury to his face. Dr carniol came about a half an hour later and stitched up my sons wound. Before that, He prepped me for what to expect (this was my first time ever and it was a difficult thing to go through). He did an awesome job keeping us all calm during the process and my sons eyebrow healed beautifully.

• Maria Apostolatos 5 Stars!    The whole team was so kind and attentive and helped me feel as comfortable as possible during my mohs surgery. Dr. Carniol is great.

• AC 5 Stars!  Dr. Carniol is the best! From start to finish he was thorough. He explained how and what the procedure would look like. Not only did he make you feel comfortable about what he was going to do but he also took time to get to know you as a patient. The results are nothing short of amazing.  I highly recommend Dr. Carnoil! Thank you Dr. Carniol, Nurse Laura and staff for making my procedure seamless!

• Cheri Jeter 5 Stars!   I had a raised mole removed from my tattooed eyebrow. I am beyond pleased with the results! The scar is smooth and within the shape of the eyebrow. You can barely see it! Highly recommend services here. The staff is very pleasant and Dr E Carniol is so nice and very clear of his intentions and results.
• Nora 5 Stars!   Thank you Dr Eric Carniol for successfully removing the slow growing tumor under Jeremy’s Right eye, which no other physician- surgeon wanted to try. He has been back to work program at Life Skills. Thank you to his team, anesthesiologists, OR same day sx, OR & recovery team,RN’s Tamako & Lexi at Overlook Hospital. Thank you for your expertise & skills , kindness, professionalism, & dedication to your profession. May your Tribe increaser
• Fran Bell 5 Stars!  Carniol Plastic Surgery, specifically Dr Eric Carniol, and the staff have been wonderful.  I saw Dr Carniol after MOHS surgery and I am completely satisfied. After healing from that plastic surgery he identified and then helped me with a deviated septum.  Again, I am very satisfied. I always felt like a priority

• Terri Burroughs 5 Stars!   I had a really good experience with Dr Carniol. I had a small cysts near my mouth that needed to be removed and after trying a couple of other plastic surgeons, I was pleasantly surprised by how nice and helpful the front deck staff was when I called to make my appointment. The extra attentiveness and care made me feel welcome and comforted in my decision to choose this practice. My first appointment was really good. I was given tons of information so that I could make an informed decision, which I did. I felt that at very point, I was given the chance to ask questions and voice any concerns. Lastly, I am really happy with the results following the procedure. There is very minimal scarring and no pain. I finally have my smile back and I couldn’t be happier.

Esinam Quarcoo 5 Stars!   Dr. Carniol is an excellent surgeon! He and his staff go above and beyond to provide top notch patient care throughout the treatment experience. I am so pleased with my results and would not hesitate to refer others to the practice.

Dr. Patricia Peterson-Bland 5 Stars!  Initially, I was apprehensive about the whole plastic surgery thing.  Dr. Carniol explained the procedure and provided several options. During my consultation with Dr. Carniol, he made me feel comfortable and attended to my concerns.  I am more than, pleased with the results and highly recommend Dr. Carniol! His staff is amazing!

Brittany Kelly 5 Stars!   The staff and service provided is top tier.

Carolyn Galant 5 Stars!   Dr. Paul Carniol and his team create a wonderful experience, they are caring and experts, results were great!

Albert Chesley 5 Stars!   My wife had to have surgery, both doctors were present.  Everything went perfectly.  The staff was incredible in the office as well.  We were very happy and would highly recommend father and son.

Shailly Jain 5 Stars!

Yana Kleter 5 Stars!  Dr. Carniol and his staff are beyond words incredible.  Their warmth and diligence is incomparable. Highly recommend!

Marge Solomon 5 Stars!  Excellent communication skills and advice! Both doctor ans assistant were empathetic and very knowledgeable! Dr Carniol was excellent in his manner and accommodating in his willingness to see me right away! I appreciated all of his medical expertise!! Thank you!!

Patrick 5 Stars!  Excellent physician. Personable, knowledgeable, caring. He never rushed any of my appointments and provided stellar care before and after my procedure. Highly recommend.